Camas Prairie, Elmore County, Idaho

Category Archives: More Info

Energy sprawl threatens Kittitas County tourism

Originally published by the Yakima Herald on May 5, 2018.
The following article is an editorial written about a proposed wind farm that could be built just north of the town of Ellensburg, Washington. Ellensburg is located in central Washinton just off Interstate 90.

Overlooking Camas Prairie where 30-40 huge wind towers could soon be built.

Written By: Kathi Pritchard and Mark Pritchard |  May 5, 2018

Kittitas County has an award-winning tourism sector. Yet the county will struggle to reap the benefits of recent investments when the state’s energy siting council approves its fourth energy project in the Kittitas valley just north of downtown Ellensburg.

“At almost 500 feet, nearly as tall as Seattle’s Space Needle, these will be the tallest seen on U.S. soil.” [the same size wind towers planned for Elmore County]

A French multinational corporation just asked the council to approve 31 giant turbines. At almost 500 feet, nearly as tall as Seattle’s Space Needle, these will be the tallest seen on U.S. soil. Spanning 4,400 acres along Highway 97, this energy project will threaten tourism efforts, stifling growth in local jobs and tax revenues.

The Chamber of Commerce and other local groups teamed up to create a tourism theme emphasizing the area’s rural roots such as the “Barn Quilt Trail Map”, “Hometown Holidays” and the Ellensburg Rodeo. The county carved a niche that complements more established promotions like Yakima’s wine country and Leavenworth. These strategies depend on the same asset to draw tourists, the scenic attractiveness of rural landscapes.

This is what the Cat Creek Summit Scenic Overlook in Elmore County, Idaho would look like if our local wind farm gets approved. This is bad for tourism.

Gov. Jay Inslee recently recognized tourism as a major vehicle for building stronger rural communities by approving tourism bill SB 5251. Washington’s Tourism Office aims to promote natural wonders, hiking, and outdoor recreation opportunities throughout the state. However, tourism assets become liabilities when energy developments dominate the landscape.

“Studies report wind turbines dramatically decrease the attractiveness of a destination for tourists.”

Research from Europe, where wind turbines have operated for 25 years, offers insights for decision-makers here. Studies report wind turbines dramatically decrease the attractiveness of a destination for tourists. A 2015 study of 2200 German communities show taller turbines create the strongest negative impact on tourism. Research from Scotland is making similar headlines that 55 percent of tourists are “less likely to visit areas of the countryside industrialized by giant turbines.” Deploying turbines across Scotland’s scenic highlands also reduced tourism jobs by 7 to 14 percent in affected areas. Scotland’s policy outlines a standard for compensating communities, roughly $7,000 per megawatt from energy developers. Elected officials advocate for “a fair share in the revenues generated from their natural resources.”

“55 percent of tourists are “less likely to visit areas of the countryside industrialized by giant turbines.”

Scotland and Germany are not alone in voicing concerns. England’s popular Lake District will dismantle wind turbines this summer. Local groups say dismantling turbines restores views. In the U.S., rural communities face the same dilemma.

“Tourism will not flourish when over half of tourists avoid visiting areas with industrial-scale energy.”

Tourism will not flourish when over half of tourists avoid visiting areas with industrial-scale energy.

Tourism is the state’s fourth largest industry and weathers economic downturns better than most. State employment data report tourism delivered the largest increase in Kittitas County jobs from 2004-2016. Tourism jobs increased by 66 percent locally, with accommodations and food services accounting the majority of all new jobs added. By contrast, government jobs, including Central Washington University, decreased by 22 percent during the same period.

“Looking at these data, it is safe to say that tourism is extremely important to the Kittitas County labor market,” said Don Meseck, the state’s regional economist. No other non-farm industry makes as strong a contribution to the local economy.

For tourism to grow in our rural communities, Washington needs a moratorium on permitting new energy projects. Policymakers should consider land-use conflicts that threaten the scenic vistas vital to tourism’s success.

“We cannot afford to damage our natural assets in ways that would deter visitors from returning,” according to Gov. Paul LePage.

As a state, we could learn from Maine’s moratorium on permits for new wind turbines. Gauging effects on rural tourism is an important issue for our state. “We cannot afford to damage our natural assets in ways that would deter visitors from returning,” according to Gov. Paul LePage.

A moratorium on energy siting is critical here for tourism’s development. A statewide vision of tourism’s future and the long-term economic welfare of our communities is at stake.


* Kathi Pritchard served as county director of tourism in Oregon, promoting the state to U.S. and international markets, and more recently worked as a communications consultant for British Columbia’s Ministry of the Attorney General.

* Mark Pritchard, PhD, is a professor in the College of Business at Central Washington University. He lectures on destination branding to graduate students in France and the U.S., and has served as a consultant for state tourism agencies in British Columbia, the Yukon Territory, Arizona, Oregon, and Western Australia. They live in Ellensburg.

Permission to reuse this guest editorial was granted by Professor Mark Pritchard on June 1, 2018.
Permission to reuse this article was granted by Frank Purdy, Editor of the Yakima Herald-Republic on May 30, 2018.
See: https://www.yakimaherald.com/opinion/editorials/guest_editorials/energy-sprawl-threatens-kittitas-county-tourism/article_46749a3a-4fdc-11e8-91dc-b3ca1f7908bb.html

Video Location Of The Cat Creek Energy Wind Farm

“The planned Cat Creek Energy wind farm on Camas Prairie is a bad idea!” – Chris Stephens from the S Bar Ranch

The video below was taken on May 19, 2018, at 1:30 pm near the intersection of Cat Creek Road and Bennett Mountain Road in Elmore County, Idaho. The location gives a spectacular view of the Camas Prairie and the snowcapped Soldier Mountains in the distance. With Cat Creek Energy, LLC’s plan to construct between 30 and 40 wind turbines within the viewshed of this video, it’s easy to understand why we think the Elmore County Commissioners should put an end to this project.

The Video & Where Was It Taken?

The video is geotagged at 43.288762, -115.317848.
A link to a map of the location can be found at https://goo.gl/maps/JhxTYcGMixq

A total of eight or nine wind towers as tall as a 50 story skyscraper will be located within one mile of the video location unless we can convince Elmore County officials and the Cat Creek Energy leadership that a wind farm does not belong on Camas Prairie.

What Can You Do?

Share the video: https://youtu.be/jT0TxrTyaIk

Take a drive up to the western portions of Camas Prairie and see for yourself the beauty of this area.

Contact the Elmore County Commissioners, Wes Wootan, Bud Corbus and Al Hofer and explain to them a wind farm in that planned location is a bad idea. The contact information for the commissioners can be found on the county website at http://www.elmorecounty.org/Commissioners/PDFs/default.html

If the project gets approval, the wind towers at the scenic viewpoint would look like this. Click for a larger version of this bad idea.

The Cat Creek Project Will Get A New Public Rehearing

Project Approval Rehearing will be scheduled soon

A rehearing on the amendments to the approval and conditions contemplated by the Elmore County/Cat Creek Energy Development Agreement will be scheduled very soon.

If that lead sentence didn’t confuse you, then it’s likely you have a legal background somewhere in your DNA.

Yes, this whole Cat Creek Energy project is a complex and data-intensive issue. Starting today we will try to simplify some of the legal and technical aspects surrounding our objections, and many of your objections as well, to this entire project. They say, “knowledge is power,” so a good start to gaining that knowledge is reading or skimming the documentation Elmore County drafted for the upcoming rehearing. 

Download the full 14-page pdf by clicking here …  May 18, 2018 - Elmore County Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order Document

The hotlink to the document can be found here … http://catcreek-energy.com/download/234/r

 

 

View the Petition For Judicial Review – Lawsuit Complaint Document

The S Bar Ranch filed a lawsuit against Elmore County, Idaho on May 1, 2018. You can download and view this document through a link at the bottom of this post.

CCE Notice of Appeal sign
CCE’s Notice of Appeal sign is barely visible on Wood Creek Road off Highway 20.

A snippet from this petition for judicial review states:
11. Cat Creek appealed the Commission’s Decision to the Elmore County (“ County” )
Board of Commissioners (“ Board” ).
12. The Board held a hearing on the appeal of the Commission’s Decision on
November 16, 2016, at which time Cat Creek presented new evidence, for the first time, that
materially changed the CUPs, including a new master site plan.
13. This new evidence was not properly noticed as part of the hearing and S Bar
Ranch did not have a proper opportunity to respond to this new evidence.

Click here to download the pdf document  View the Petition For Judicial Review - Lawsuit Complaint

Download of a copy of the reconsideration hearing paperwork

A snippet of the April 31, 2018 document.

A snippet from this legal document:

“The basis for this Supplement to the Second Request for Reconsideration is failure of the
Elmore County Board of County Commissioners (Commissioners” ) and Elmore County
(County” ) in general, to comply with the requirements of the Local Land Use Planning Act, Idaho
Code Section 676501 …”

Click below to start the pdf download.

Supplement to Second Request for Reconsideration - filed April 31, 2018

Help Stop A Wind Farm On Camas Prairie, Idaho

Here is a 70-second video showing where Cat Creek Energy, LLC plans to build a wind farm on the western edge of Camas Prairie in southern Idaho in the coming months. We believe this wind farm will ruin the scenic value of the area, lead to a proliferation of more wind farms along the Highway 20 corridor and disrupt the migration patterns of the many elk that roam this portion of the state.

Please help us get word to the Elmore County Commissioners this wind farm is a bad idea.

Additionally, there is a reconsideration hearing on May 11, 2018, where the commissioner could reopen the discussion for the approval of Cat Creek Energy, LLC’s five conditional use permits (CUPs) for this project. We believe the permitting process was flawed and the approval process should be reopened. If you could attend this 1:30 pm meeting, it will make a big impression on the decision makers.

Commissioner Contact Information

Please share this video and post with your friends and neighbors if you oppose the construction of 31 oversized wind turbines on the road to Anderson Ranch Reservoir, Fairfield, Sun Valley and Craters of the Moon National Monument.

Thanks,

 

Tim

The CCE Wind Farm is “Out of Line” From Other Idaho Wind Farms

The proposed wind farm on the western fringes of Camas Prairie and in the scenic Cat Creek Summit area of Idaho’s Highway 20 is a departure from the standards used for other wind farms projects in our state.

The map below shows that all wind farms/turbines in Idaho are located along the Interstate 84 and Interstate 15 corridors. The Cat Creek Energy project could very well open up a whole new eye-sore corridor along Highway 20 and maybe even along the approaches to Anderson Ranch Reservoir on the Pine-Featherville Road.

Click on the map below for a larger version

2018 wind farm locations in Idaho and the proposed location of CCE wind farm.

Currently, the 588 wind turbines shown on the above map produce 1,026 megawatts of energy according to the United States Geologic Survey. That is enough energy to power over 750,000 households (1 megawatt – 750 households). As of the 2016 U.S. Census estimates, there were about 600,000 households in Idaho.

588 wind turbines already produce enough energy for more households than are located in Idaho.

Are you willing to hedge your bets and simply trust that this new Cat Creek Energy wind farm will not open up the floodgates for future projects up and down Highway 20 and other connecting corridors?

Get Involved

On May 11, 2018, at 1:30 pm, the Elmore County Commissioners will decide if they think they should take a better look at the process they used to approve this large-scale energy project and the 10,000 pages of evidence. Please contact the county commissioners (http://www.elmorecounty.org/Commissioners/PDFs/default.html) to voice your opinion and if you have time, attend this critical meeting.

Reference:

https://eerscmap.usgs.gov/uswtdb/viewer/#6.44/43.983/-112.802
http://enduse.lbl.gov/Info/CA_Presentation/sld011.htm


Last updated on April 27, 2018